Corruption is regarded as the mother of ills in society and rightly so. Sadly, in Pakistan, there is hardly any institution that is free from this disease and it has been affecting the whole society from bureaucracy to politics to education. But the impact of corruption on education has many dimensions and is multifaceted. Before talking about the effects of corruption on the education system of Pakistan, it is pertinent to trace the reasons and causes that make the environment feasible for corruption to exist.

Reasons for corruption in the education sector in Pakistan

Corruption has been a pervasive problem in Pakistan’s education sector for decades. The phenomenon of corruption in the education sector can be attributed to a range of factors, including political interference, lack of transparency, weak governance structures, inadequate funding, and limited accountability mechanisms. This article aims to provide a detailed analysis of the root causes of corruption in Pakistan’s education sector and its impact on the country’s overall development.

Political Interference:

Political interference is one of the main reasons for corruption in Pakistan’s education sector. Politicians use their power to appoint individuals who are loyal to them to key positions within the education system. This often results in the appointment of unqualified and incompetent individuals who lack the necessary skills and experience to perform their duties effectively. Additionally, politicians often manipulate the allocation of education funds, diverting resources to their own constituencies or personal projects, rather than investing in the development of the education system as a whole.

Lack of Transparency:

Another contributing factor to corruption in Pakistan’s education sector is the lack of transparency in decision-making processes. There is often a lack of public access to information about the allocation and disbursement of education funds, making it easier for corrupt officials to siphon off funds without being detected. Additionally, contracts for the provision of goods and services, such as textbooks or school buildings, are often awarded without any competitive bidding process, making it easier for corrupt officials to award contracts to their preferred suppliers.

Weak Governance Structures:

The weak governance structures in Pakistan’s education sector also contribute to corruption. The system lacks adequate checks and balances, which makes it easier for corrupt officials to engage in fraudulent activities. Additionally, regulatory bodies, such as the Higher Education Commission (HEC) and the Education Boards, lack capacity to effectively monitor and regulate the education sector. This lack of oversight and regulation makes it easier for corrupt officials to engage in corrupt practices with impunity.

Inadequate Funding:

Another factor contributing to corruption in Pakistan’s education sector is inadequate funding. Pakistan spends a meager percentage of its GDP on education, which has resulted in a chronic lack of resources for the sector. This lack of resources has made it difficult for schools and universities to provide quality education to students. As a result, teachers and administrators often resort to corrupt practices to supplement their income, such as accepting bribes or charging illegal fees.

Limited Accountability Mechanisms:

Finally, limited accountability mechanisms in the education sector have also contributed to corruption. There are few consequences for officials who engage in corrupt practices, and the punishments that do exist are often not severe enough to deter corruption. Additionally, there is a lack of whistleblower protection, which discourages individuals from reporting corruption for fear of retaliation.

Impacts of Corruption on the Education Sector

The impacts of corruption in the education sector are far-reaching and have led to a decline in the quality of education, unequal access to education, and a lack of transparency in the allocation of resources. In this article, we will examine the impacts of corruption in the education sector in Pakistan.

One of the most significant impacts of corruption in the education sector is the decline in the quality of education. Corruption has led to the hiring of unqualified teachers, the sale of grades and degrees, and the allocation of resources to schools based on bribery rather than need. As a result, the education system is failing to produce competent graduates who can contribute positively to the economy and society.

Furthermore, corruption has led to unequal access to education, particularly for children from low-income families. In many cases, parents must pay bribes to get their children into schools or to ensure that they receive a quality education. This has created a system where education is only available to those who can afford to pay for it, perpetuating the cycle of poverty and inequality.

Corruption has also led to a lack of transparency in the allocation of resources for the education sector. Funds intended for education are often misused or embezzled, with little accountability or oversight. This has resulted in a shortage of resources for schools, including textbooks, facilities, and qualified teachers. In addition, corruption has resulted in the development of ghost schools, where funding is allocated for schools that do not exist, or schools that exist only on paper.

The impact of corruption in the education sector has also contributed to the radicalization of youth in Pakistan. A lack of access to education, coupled with the prevalence of madrassas that teach extremist ideologies, has led to a generation of young people who are vulnerable to recruitment by extremist groups. This has contributed to the rise of extremism and terrorism in Pakistan.

In addition, corruption has led to a brain drain of qualified professionals from the education sector. Many competent teachers and professors have left Pakistan to pursue opportunities abroad, where they can receive better salaries and working conditions. This has resulted in a shortage of qualified educators, particularly in rural areas, where the situation is particularly dire.

The impact of corruption in the education sector has also contributed to a decline in the international reputation of Pakistan. International organizations and foreign governments are increasingly reluctant to invest in the education sector in Pakistan due to concerns about corruption and the lack of accountability. This has further exacerbated the shortage of resources for education in Pakistan.

To address the issue of corruption in the education sector, it is essential to strengthen accountability and transparency mechanisms. This includes improving oversight and monitoring of education funds, establishing an independent body to investigate corruption in the sector, and creating a system of rewards and punishments for educators based on performance.

In addition, it is crucial to invest in education and to ensure that funds are allocated based on need rather than bribery. This includes increasing funding for education, particularly in rural areas, where the situation is particularly dire, and providing incentives for qualified educators to work in these areas.

Finally, there is a need to address the issue of madrassas, which are often seen as an alternative to the failing public education system. To address this issue, it is essential to reform the public education system to provide access to quality education for all children, regardless of their socioeconomic status. This includes providing incentives for private schools to open in areas where public education is failing, investing in teacher training and curriculum development, and improving the quality of facilities and resources available to students.

In conclusion, corruption in the education sector in Pakistan has had far-reaching impacts on the quality of education, access to education, and the reputation of the country. To address this issue, it is essential to strengthen accountability and transparency mechanisms.

Related: ACE Punjab joins hands with UMT to Fight Corruption

The concept of blended learning revolves around the combination and amalgamation of both modern and traditional tools and modes of education, whereas the traditional modes of knowledge primarily focus on in-person learning while the modern mode talks about using the technological tool to enhance the learning experience of students, tools such as the distance learning, online learning and using AI integrated tools for the educational development of the society.

Talking about Pakistan, there’s a case that needs to be presented that universities should opt for the model of Blended Learning. Universities can benefit from implementing blended learning by improving student engagement, increasing access to higher education, and enhancing academic outcomes. However, the adoption of blended learning requires strategic planning, faculty training, technological infrastructure, and policy support.

To opt for blended learning in Pakistani universities, the first step is to create a comprehensive plan that aligns with the institution’s vision, mission, and goals. The plan should include an analysis of the current state of education, the potential benefits and challenges of blended learning, and the desired outcomes. The plan should also involve all stakeholders, including students, faculty, administrators, and IT staff.

Faculty training is a critical component of blended learning adoption. Instructors need to learn how to design and deliver online content, facilitate online discussions, provide feedback, and assess student learning. They also need to be familiar with the learning management system (LMS) and other technology tools used in blended learning. Therefore, universities should offer professional development opportunities, such as workshops, seminars, and online courses, to help faculty gain the necessary skills and knowledge.

The technological infrastructure is another essential element of blended learning adoption. Universities must ensure that they have the necessary hardware, software, and networking capabilities to support online learning. The LMS should be robust and user-friendly, allowing students to access course materials, participate in discussions, submit assignments, and receive feedback. Additionally, universities should invest in online resources, such as e-books, journals, and multimedia, to supplement traditional classroom instruction.

Pakistani universities also need to develop policies and guidelines to support blended learning. These policies should address issues such as academic integrity, student privacy, intellectual property, accessibility, and quality assurance. The policies should be consistent with international standards and best practices and should be communicated effectively to all stakeholders.

Finally, Pakistani universities should evaluate the effectiveness of blended learning implementation regularly. Evaluation should include both quantitative and qualitative data, such as student performance, satisfaction, retention, and graduation rates, as well as faculty and student feedback. The evaluation results should inform continuous improvement efforts and help universities refine their blended learning strategies.

In conclusion, blended learning has the potential to transform higher education in Pakistan by improving access, quality, and outcomes. However, adopting blended learning requires careful planning, faculty training, technological infrastructure, policy support, and ongoing evaluation. Pakistani universities should prioritize blended learning adoption and work collaboratively to ensure its successful implementation.

Challenges of Blended learning in Pakistan

Like any new educational approach, it presents its own set of challenges. In Pakistan, a developing country with a large population, the challenges of implementing blended learning are particularly pronounced. This article will explore the challenges of blended learning in Pakistan and discuss potential solutions to these challenges.

Infrastructure

One of the primary challenges of blended learning in Pakistan is infrastructure. According to the World Bank, only about 22% of the population in Pakistan has access to the internet, and even fewer have access to high-speed internet. In addition, many schools in Pakistan lack basic infrastructure such as electricity, computers, and reliable internet connectivity. Without the necessary infrastructure, it is difficult to implement blended learning, which requires students to have access to computers, the internet, and other technology.

To address this challenge, the government of Pakistan has launched several initiatives aimed at improving access to technology and infrastructure. For example, the government has launched the “Digital Pakistan” initiative, which aims to provide broadband internet access to all parts of the country. In addition, the government has partnered with private companies to provide laptops and other devices to students at affordable prices.

Teacher Training

Another challenge of blended learning in Pakistan is the need for teacher training. Many teachers in Pakistan lack the necessary skills and training to effectively implement blended learning in their classrooms. They may not know how to use technology to deliver instruction or how to assess student learning in an online environment.

To address this challenge, the government of Pakistan has launched several teacher training programs aimed at improving the digital skills of teachers. For example, the government has launched the “Teacher Training and Development Program,” which provides training to teachers in digital skills such as using learning management systems and creating online content.

Language Barrier

In Pakistan, there are several languages spoken in different regions, and many students may not be proficient in the national language, Urdu. This presents a challenge in implementing blended learning, as much of the online content may be in Urdu or English, which many students may not understand.

To address this challenge, schools and education providers may need to provide online content in multiple languages. In addition, teachers may need to be trained in how to deliver instruction in multiple languages to ensure that all students can understand the content.

Lack of Engagement

Blended learning may not be engaging for all students, particularly those who are used to traditional classroom instruction. Without proper engagement, students may not be motivated to learn, which can impact their academic performance.

To address this challenge, schools and education providers may need to use gamification techniques and other strategies to make online learning more engaging. For example, they may use online quizzes, interactive games, and other digital tools to keep students engaged and motivated.

Assessment and Evaluation

Another challenge of blended learning in Pakistan is assessment and evaluation. It can be difficult to assess student learning in an online environment, particularly if the assessment is based on written work or traditional exams.

To address this challenge, schools and education providers may need to use a combination of online and traditional assessment methods. For example, they may use online quizzes and assignments, as well as traditional exams and written work, to assess student learning.

Conclusion

Blended learning has the potential to transform education in Pakistan, but it also presents several challenges. The government and education providers in Pakistan will need to work together to address these challenges and ensure that all students have access to high-quality education. This will require investments in infrastructure, teacher training, and the development of engaging and effective online content. By addressing these challenges, Pakistan can unlock the full potential of blended learning and provide students with the skills and knowledge they need to succeed in the 21st century.

Related: Does blended learning have a future in Pakistan?

E-learning has emerged as a powerful tool to enhance the quality of higher education in recent years. With the rapid advancements in technology, e-learning has become increasingly accessible and effective in providing students with a high-quality education.

One of the key advantages of e-learning is the flexibility it offers. Students can access learning materials and engage in coursework at their own pace and on their own schedule, which allows them to balance their academic pursuits with other commitments such as work or family obligations. Additionally, e-learning allows students to access a wider range of courses and programs than they might have otherwise been able to, as it eliminates the barriers of geography and time zones.

Benefits of E-Learning:

E-learning is a rapidly growing trend in the world of education, offering numerous benefits to learners, educators, and organizations. From its flexibility to its cost-effectiveness, E-learning has transformed the way we learn and teach, providing an array of opportunities that traditional classrooms cannot match. Here are some of the benefits of E-learning:

Flexibility

One of the significant benefits of E-learning is its flexibility. Learners can access course material and complete assignments from anywhere, at any time, and on any device. This allows individuals to learn at their own pace and according to their schedule, which is especially helpful for those with work or family commitments.

Cost-effectiveness

E-learning is cost-effective for both learners and organizations. Online courses typically cost less than traditional classroom courses, and there are no additional expenses associated with travel, accommodation, or equipment. Organizations can save on costs related to hiring trainers, renting facilities, and printing materials.

Personalization

E-learning allows learners to personalize their learning experience based on their individual needs and preferences. Online courses offer a range of multimedia resources, interactive tools, and assessment methods that cater to different learning styles. This enables learners to choose the content and activities that are most relevant and engaging to them.

Accessibility

E-learning makes education accessible to a broader range of individuals, including those who live in remote areas, have mobility or health issues, or are unable to attend traditional classrooms. Online courses are designed to be accessible for people with disabilities, with features such as closed captioning, screen readers, and alternative text.

Enhanced collaboration

E-learning provides opportunities for collaboration and interaction among learners, educators, and experts from around the world. Online forums, chat rooms, and video conferencing allow learners to connect with others and share ideas, experiences, and feedback. This enhances the learning experience and promotes a sense of community and belonging.

How E-Learning can bridge the Educational Divide in Pakistan

Pakistan is a country that is plagued with a wide educational divide, with significant disparities in access to quality education between urban and rural areas, as well as gender-based disparities. The COVID-19 pandemic has further exacerbated this divide, as schools across the country have been closed for extended periods of time, depriving millions of children of their right to education. However, e-learning has emerged as a potential solution to bridge this gap and ensure that every child has access to quality education, regardless of their location or gender.

One of the key benefits of e-learning is its ability to reach learners in remote and underserved areas, where traditional schools may not be available or may be of poor quality. According to the Pakistan Education Statistics Report 2019-2020, there are approximately 22.8 million out-of-school children in the country, with the majority of them living in rural areas. E-learning can provide these children with access to quality educational content and resources, such as online courses, videos, interactive games, and quizzes, that they would not otherwise have access to.

Another advantage of e-learning is that it can be personalized to meet the individual needs of learners. Through the use of adaptive learning technologies, e-learning platforms can analyze a learner’s performance and adjust the content and pace of instruction to match their learning style and level of understanding. This personalized approach can help to improve learning outcomes, as learners are more engaged and motivated when the content is tailored to their needs.

E-learning can also help to address gender-based disparities in education. In Pakistan, girls are less likely to enroll in school and are more likely to drop out than boys. According to the Pakistan Education Statistics Report 2019-2020, the net enrollment rate for girls at the primary level is 72%, compared to 76% for boys. E-learning can provide girls with a safe and secure learning environment, where they can access educational content without the risk of discrimination or harassment. Moreover, e-learning can help to overcome traditional barriers to girls’ education, such as the need to travel long distances to school or the need to balance household chores with schoolwork.

Challenges in E-Learning

E-learning in Pakistan is facing several challenges that need to be addressed to make it more effective and accessible.

Infrastructure

One of the main challenges that e-learning faces in Pakistan is the lack of infrastructure. Many areas in the country do not have access to the internet, and where it is available, it is often slow and unreliable. This makes it difficult for students and teachers to access online materials, videos, and other resources. To address this challenge, the government needs to invest in the development of the necessary infrastructure to ensure that all students and teachers have access to high-speed internet.

Access to Devices

Another significant challenge is the lack of access to devices such as computers, laptops, and tablets. Many students in Pakistan cannot afford to purchase these devices, which makes it difficult for them to participate in online learning. In addition, many schools do not have the resources to provide these devices to their students. To overcome this challenge, the government and private organizations need to work together to provide students with access to affordable devices.

Quality of Content

The quality of content available online is another significant challenge facing e-learning in Pakistan. Much of the content available is not tailored to the needs of Pakistani students, and may not be culturally appropriate. This makes it difficult for students to engage with the material and may lead to a lack of interest in learning. To overcome this challenge, there needs to be a concerted effort to develop high-quality, relevant content that is tailored to the needs of Pakistani students.

Teacher Training

Teacher training is another significant challenge facing e-learning in Pakistan. Many teachers are not familiar with online teaching methods and do not have the necessary skills to create or deliver online content effectively. To address this challenge, the government needs to provide training and support to teachers to help them develop the necessary skills to deliver online content effectively.

Language Barrier

The language barrier is another significant challenge facing e-learning in Pakistan. Much of the content available online is in English, which may be a barrier for students who are not fluent in the language. To overcome this challenge, there needs to be more content available in Urdu, the national language of Pakistan, and other regional languages.

Cost

The cost of e-learning is also a significant challenge facing students in Pakistan. Many families cannot afford to pay for online courses, which makes it difficult for students to participate in e-learning. To address this challenge, the government needs to work with private organizations to develop affordable e-learning solutions that are accessible to all students.

Conclusion

E-learning has the potential to revolutionize the education sector in Pakistan, but there are significant challenges that need to be addressed. Infrastructure, access to devices, quality of content, teacher training, language barrier, and cost are all significant challenges that need to be addressed to make e-learning more effective and accessible. The government needs to work with private organizations to develop a comprehensive strategy to overcome these challenges and ensure that all students have access to high-quality education.

Related: VCs Commit To Making E-Learning Successful

The last weekend had been a rich experience for me as the country celebrated its mother languages week. During my engagement with many linguist scholars and language rights advocates, I was amazed by the diversity of powerful viewpoints the idea carried. It provided me with an opportunity to start looking into the matter more systematically as it does affect both the teacher and his/her students in their learning environments. A major barrier to education, and perhaps a primary source of our learning barriers, is caused by keeping a child away from his/her mother language. Language has a direct link with a child’s cognition. And that cognition cannot be developed without a child getting internally acclimatized to his/her surroundings. There are many beautiful initiatives undertaken by our own local educators (heroes) who have internalized systems of learning that helped children have fun with learning solely because of the comfort and acceptance they have found in such environments. But all such extraordinary steps get wiped away when the state imposes its diction on uniform learning systems; and we can’t get out of our binary of English and Urdu medium of instruction and learning in public schools. That’s one viewpoint on language rights, strongly adhere to.

The other viewpoint is more nationalistic which stems from the resentment of communities that feel that their fundamental cultural identity is being robbed of them by the hegemony of Urdu, which is the sole official language of Pakistan. During discussions, a debate arose about whether or not Urdu should be considered a lingua franca, a common language among different communities, but the idea was opposed by other language proponents on the ground that Urdu might actually become an obstacle itself between two language communities because consequently, each group will fail to make an effort to understand each other’s way of talking. The idea was further supported by the perception that people can begin to understand each other through mere words and simple actions, and this will enable them to familiarise themselves with how they communicate and learn with each other in their own language. This way, they become more immersed with each other, however, if there is another language to be used between them, their direct interaction runs the risk of becoming restrictive and alienated.

This is a very persuasive viewpoint on language nationalism, but I found many other questions unfold: what happens in the context of technological advancements in a heavily globalized world where vocabulary and languages are shifting from their conventional paradigms and moving towards more universal languages? It is a civilizational evolution that is bound to occur as no language could remain static or in silos for a long time. In times of high-paced technology and scientific advancements, commonalities are crucial for sharing of information and knowledge. That is where I tend to disagree with the nationalist political perspective of keeping languages “pure”. I do, however, believe that languages need to be preserved because they carry with them important history and lessons that we can learn from. But keeping it from evolving and absorbing changes as communities interact will only make it irrelevant and redundant ultimately.

The third viewpoint is legislative hegemony of language; whereas article 28, the fundamental right to preserve language, script and culture, but that is subject to article 251 which stipulates Urdu as an official language. Many attempts had been made to amend the said article so it could accommodate the required official status of other spoken languages as well, but it could not get through on technical hindrances. The promotion of local languages was legislated in the provinces of Balochistan and Khyber Pakhtunkhwa as well, but they are nowhere near implementation as they become subject to bureacratic obstacles. This is the reason why all 77 local languages are perishing, out of which 28 are in extreme danger of extinction. This should be a major concern for the state, as the loss of a language here means a loss of heritage. Although it’s hard to revive a dying language, preserving a language for the sake of saving knowledge and wisdom it carried through the ages becomes more than a national responsibility.

The writer, Zeeba Hashmi, is the founder of Ibtidah for Education (IFE), an educationist, she tweets: @zeebahashmi

Related: Urdu as a medium of instruction can boost student learning: Raas

The role of a teacher in any student’s life can not be emphasized enough, as it is as important as the role usually played by the parents, because in modern times, children get admitted to School in the formative years of their age and they learn basic life skills from their teachers and unconsciously try to imitate them. And in higher education too, although it is not talked about much, mentors play a very crucial role in shaping the future of researchers and academics and help them choose a career path that will unleash the hidden potential of the students. Hence, the Student-Teacher Relationship carries the utmost significance as far as the learning and the growth of the student are concerned, and it should be given the kind of attention it deserves if we are really interested in developing individuals who are equipped with modern tools and critical thinking and knowledge development. It can also be regarded as the most influential factor in the learning journey of any individual.

Talking about Pakistan, the Student-Teacher relationship is often misunderstood and ignored as there is no mechanism in place to bridge the gaps between students and teachers. Often in government and public institutions, students are treated as entities and subjects to be taught only discipline through strict punishments without taking their subjective experience into consideration. We universities and educational institutions just focus on managing the affairs of the students, and instead of making children feel safe, they end up widening the existing gap between teachers and students.

A teacher who takes the time to build a relationship with their students can better understand their strengths and weaknesses. This allows them to tailor their teaching approach to the individual needs of each student, resulting in better academic outcomes. For instance, a teacher who knows that a student struggles with a particular concept can take a different approach to teach the concept, making it more accessible to the student.

A positive student-teacher relationship can also influence a student’s motivation to learn. A teacher who is passionate about their subject and is invested in their student’s success can inspire students to take an interest in the subject. In contrast, a teacher who is disinterested and distant can make students feel disconnected from the subject, resulting in a lack of motivation to learn.

Moreover, a positive student-teacher relationship can have a significant impact on a student’s overall development. Teachers serve as role models for their students, and their behavior and attitude can shape the students’ values, beliefs, and attitudes. A teacher who models positive behaviors and values can help students develop their social skills, such as communication, empathy, and teamwork.

Additionally, a positive student-teacher relationship can help students feel supported and valued. Teachers who show an interest in their students’ personal lives can create a sense of belonging in the classroom, making students feel more connected to the learning environment. This, in turn, can have a positive impact on their mental health and emotional wellbeing.

In contrast, a negative student-teacher relationship can have a detrimental effect on a student’s academic performance and personal development. A teacher who is disengaged, unapproachable, or critical can make students feel unsupported and undervalued. This can result in a lack of motivation to learn, poor academic performance, and negative emotional outcomes such as stress, anxiety, and depression.

Furthermore, a negative student-teacher relationship can lead to disciplinary issues in the classroom. A teacher who does not have a positive relationship with their students may struggle to maintain classroom management and discipline. This can result in disruptive behavior, poor classroom performance, and a breakdown in the learning environment.

Strategies to Build a Positive Student-Teacher Relationship:

Despite the challenges faced by teachers in Pakistan, there are strategies that can be employed to develop positive relationships with their students. These strategies include:

• Getting to Know Each Student: Teachers should take the time to get to know each student individually. This can be achieved by having one-on-one conversations with students and asking about their interests and hobbies.
• Encouraging Student Participation: Teachers should create a classroom environment that encourages student participation. This can be achieved by giving students opportunities to express their opinions, ask questions, and share their ideas.
• Providing Positive Feedback: Teachers should provide positive feedback to their students regularly. This can help to build self-esteem and confidence in their abilities.
• Being Available: Teachers should make themselves available to their students outside of class. This can be achieved by holding office hours, responding to emails promptly, and being willing to meet with students one-on-one.

Conclusion:

In conclusion, the relationship between students and teachers is a crucial factor in student academic success. In Pakistan, teachers face several challenges when it comes to building positive relationships with their students. Despite these challenges, there are strategies that teachers can employ to develop positive relationships with their students. By getting to know each student, encouraging student participation, providing positive feedback, and being available, teachers can create a positive learning environment that fosters academic success. It is essential for teachers in Pakistan to recognize the importance of positive student-teacher relationships and work to develop such relationships with their students.

Related: SELD, Google and Tech Valley ink MoU to train students and teachers